jimmythegreek Posts:12819 Followers:394
On 02/27/2013 01:42 PM in NFL


Everybody wins in Alex Smith trade to Chiefs
by Mike Freeman - cbssportsline.com

What happened in the NFL on a quiet Wednesday afternoon was something extremely rare: A trade was made in the NFL and everyone involved in the trade won. Yes, everyone.

The Chiefs win. They get Alex Smith, who despite limited arm strength and a rocky career has rebounded to where he's one of the more solid throwers in football. Smith is 20-8-1 (including the playoffs) the past two years.

The 49ers win. They will get, at least, a reported second-round pick in 2013. They have their quarterback of the future in Colin Kaepernick and now get two high picks for Smith. Those picks are gold.

Alex Smith wins. He gets to be a starter. He's rewarded for being a class act. Kaepernick wins. It's his team now. Andy Reid, coach of the Chiefs, also wins. He gets his starter to build the offense around.

See what I mean?

Sure, you can poke holes in some of the trade, or all of this, but you'd be pushing it. Smith is still relatively young, he's smart and adaptable. He's perfect for Reid's system, particularly since Reid doesn't have his pass throwers toss deep balls. His system values short-range accuracy and Smith can do that.

Smith isn't a stopgap. He can play another five years, minimum, at a top level.

This approach for Reid is far smarter than going through the draft. Who would you rather have? Matt Barkley or Alex Smith? I'll take Smith. Every personnel evaluator would take Smith for what could end up being two second-rounders.

NFL history is riddled with the carcasses of high draft picks who have gone on to be busts. Go down the list: David Carr, Todd Marinovich, JaMarcus Russell, Tim Couch, Dave Brown, Joey Harrington, Cade McNown, Akili Smith, Andre Ware, Rick Mirer and, maybe the biggest quarterback bust of all time, Ryan Leaf.

On and on it goes.

You get the proven commodity. That's it. That's all. Especially if that commodity has proven to be good.

So, for one of the first times ever, in an NFL trade:

Everyone wins.

For the latest sports news, capper picks and tracker results, turn to JTG, the leader in BTB information

  • All Time Record: 17425-17692-639
  • Last 7 Days Record: 67-66-6
  • Last 30 Days Record: 257-328-14
marksmoneymakers Posts:30746 Followers:142
02/27/2013 05:43 PM

I think that is a nice trade for everybody involved. I have never been a big Alex Smith fan though. I think he is going to struggle in KC. He was not that great with alot of talent around him in San Fran. Time will tell though.

finance Posts:9512 Followers:233
02/27/2013 05:46 PM

totally agree it's a good deal for both sides... he certainly better than anyone the chiefs would be able to get in the draft

  • All Time Record: 2227-2222-60
  • Last 7 Days Record: 13-16-1
  • Last 30 Days Record: 51-52-3