Tony Karpinski Picks History
| Pick Title | League | Game | Date | Play | Line Selected | Type | Score | Result |
| 5* | NFL | Denver vs. New England | 01/14/2012 20:00 EDT | Play on Denver | Point Spread: +14/-115 | Premium | 10 - 45 | Loss |
| 4* | NHL | Buffalo vs. NY Islanders | 01/14/2012 19:00 EDT | Play on NY Islanders | Money Line: -125 | Premium | 2 - 4 | Win |
| 10* NFL Playoff Pounder | NFL | New Orleans vs. San Francisco | 01/14/2012 16:30 EDT | Play on San Francisco | Point Spread: +4/-115 | Premium | 32 - 36 | Win |
| 4* | NCAAB | Pennsylvania vs. Columbia | 01/13/2012 19:00 EDT | Play on Pennsylvania | Point Spread: +2/-110 | Premium | 66 - 64 | Win |
| 10* Oddsmaker Mistake Game of the Week | NBA | Cleveland vs. Phoenix | 01/12/2012 21:00 EDT | Play on Phoenix | Point Spread: -7/-107 | Premium | 101 - 90 | Loss |
| 5* NHL Game of the Week | NHL | San Jose vs. Winnipeg | 01/12/2012 20:30 EDT | Play on San Jose | Money Line: -130 | Premium | 2 - 0 | Win |
| 4* | NHL | Vancouver vs. St. Louis | 01/12/2012 20:00 EDT | Play on St. Louis | Money Line: -120 | Premium | 3 - 2 | Loss |
| 4* | NCAAB | Temple vs. Saint Louis | 01/11/2012 21:00 EDT | Play on Saint Louis | Point Spread: -8/-110 | Premium | 72 - 67 | Loss |
| 4* | NBA | Dallas vs. Boston | 01/11/2012 20:00 EDT | Play on Boston | Point Spread: -5½/-102 | Premium | 90 - 85 | Loss |
| 10* College Blowout Game of the Month | NCAAB | Duquesne vs. Xavier | 01/11/2012 19:00 EDT | Play on Xavier | Point Spread: -6/-110 | Premium | 50 - 78 | Win |