Joseph D'Amico Picks History
| Pick Title | League | Game | Date | Play | Line Selected | Type | Score | Result |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF MAC Game of the Month | NCAAF | Central Michigan vs. Toledo | 10/06/2012 15:00 EDT | Play on Toledo | Point Spread: -11½/-105 | Premium | 35 - 50 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF SEC WEST Game of the Month | NCAAF | Mississippi State vs. Kentucky | 10/06/2012 12:21 EDT | Play on Mississippi State | Point Spread: -10/-105 | Premium | 27 - 14 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF BIG 10 Game of the Month | NCAAF | Michigan State vs. Indiana | 10/06/2012 12:00 EDT | Play on Michigan State | Point Spread: -14/-105 | Premium | 31 - 27 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF BIG 12 Game of the Month | NCAAF | Kansas vs. Kansas State | 10/06/2012 12:00 EDT | Play on Kansas State | Point Spread: -24½/-105 | Premium | 16 - 56 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL 2-0 Thursday Night Winner | NFL | Arizona vs. St. Louis | 10/04/2012 20:20 EDT | Play on Arizona | Point Spread: -2/-115 | Premium | 3 - 17 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL MNF Bears/Cowboys Winner | NFL | Chicago vs. Dallas | 10/01/2012 20:30 EDT | Play on Dallas | Point Spread: -3/-120 | Premium | 34 - 18 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL NFC East Game of the Month | NFL | NY Giants vs. Philadelphia | 09/30/2012 20:20 EDT | Play on NY Giants | Point Spread: +2/-105 | Premium | 17 - 19 | Push |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL Free Winner | NFL | Cincinnati vs. Jacksonville | 09/30/2012 16:05 EDT | Play on Cincinnati | Point Spread: -1/-120 | Free | 27 - 10 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL 2-0 LV Strip Move Winner | NFL | Carolina vs. Atlanta | 09/30/2012 13:00 EDT | Play on Atlanta | Point Spread: -7/-105 | Premium | 28 - 30 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL 25 Star Winner | NFL | San Francisco vs. NY Jets | 09/30/2012 13:00 EDT | Play on San Francisco | Point Spread: -3½/-110 | Premium | 34 - 0 | Win |