Joseph D'Amico Picks History
| Pick Title | League | Game | Date | Play | Line Selected | Type | Score | Result |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF Free Winner | NCAAF | Texas vs. Oklahoma | 10/13/2012 12:00 EDT | Play on Texas | Point Spread: +3½/-110 | Free | 21 - 63 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF 50 Star Winner | NCAAF | Wisconsin vs. Purdue | 10/13/2012 12:00 EDT | Play on Wisconsin | Point Spread: +2/-110 | Premium | 38 - 14 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's MLB AL East Game of the Year | MLB | Baltimore vs. NY Yankees | 10/12/2012 17:07 EDT | Play on NY Yankees | Money Line: -194 | Premium | 1 - 3 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's MLB Tigers/A's Winner | MLB | Detroit vs. Oakland | 10/11/2012 21:37 EDT | Play on Detroit | Money Line: -137 | Premium | 6 - 0 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NCAAF SunBelt Game of the Month | NCAAF | Western Kentucky vs. Troy | 10/11/2012 19:30 EDT | Play on Western Kentucky | Point Spread: -2/-105 | Premium | 31 - 26 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's MLB Giants/Reds Winner | MLB | San Francisco vs. Cincinnati | 10/11/2012 13:07 EDT | Play on Cincinnati | Money Line: -119 | Premium | 6 - 4 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's MLB Orioles/Yankees Winner | MLB | Baltimore vs. NY Yankees | 10/10/2012 19:37 EDT | Play on NY Yankees | Money Line: -164 | Premium | 2 - 3 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL Texans/Jets MNF Winner | NFL | Houston vs. NY Jets | 10/08/2012 20:30 EDT | Play on Houston | Point Spread: -8/-110 | Premium | 23 - 17 | Loss |
| Joe D'Amico's MLB Yankees/Orioles Winner | MLB | NY Yankees vs. Baltimore | 10/07/2012 18:07 EDT | Play on NY Yankees | Money Line: -154 | Premium | 7 - 2 | Win |
| Joe D'Amico's NFL Free Winner | NFL | Chicago vs. Jacksonville | 10/07/2012 16:05 EDT | Play on Chicago | Point Spread: -5½/-110 | Free | 41 - 3 | Win |